Fish Type: Cod Price: $15.00
Overall, I would recommend this Fish Fry.
| Fish Score: Good Potato Score: Good Tartar Score: Good Bread Score: Good Miscellaneous Score: Good |  |
Comment: Last time I had fish at @bennetts.meadowood it was 2010, the fish was walleye, and lunch cost $7.25. A lot has changed at the Country Club over a decade and a half, but not the Smut & Eggs…that’s just as outlandish as it ever was!
In 2026 the fish of choice is cod, and it comes in a 2 or 3-piece for lunch and/or dinner. I picked the trio since I was pretty hungry by 11:15 this Friday and I wasn’t sure what dinner would bring. I slugged down a boilerplate bloody with a snit of #CaveAle as the fish was frying and got right down to business once everything landed bar-side.
I wasn’t sure what to expect for my $15, but this cod was pretty high quality. It was flaky and white and didn’t appear to be loaded with sodium triphosphate or anything like that. The meat paired really nicely with the light and crumbly breading making for an ideal canvass for Bennett’s clingy and creamy tartar.
A handful of standard freezer fries stayed in their lane while a zesty slaw felt a step above your standard Sysco fare. Finishing it all off was a buttery slice of grilled French bread which was welcome addition and an unexpected highlight of the meal.
When something like Smut & Eggs is your calling card, the eggs had better be pretty damn good especially if the smut is pretty damn bad. That said, BMCC has clearly raised the bar and the food they put out in 2026 is anything but lewd. Overall, we recommend this Fish Fry and think you’d be wise to stop out on a Friday even if you know you’re going to end up there Saturday morning anyway.www.menupix.com/menudirectory/menu.php?id=730063
2009 Freeport Road
Madison, WI 53711
(608) 271-3827
